Friday, October 19, 2018

Getting "Woke" at the National Medicare/Medicaid & Dual Eligible Conference



As I attend the National Medical, Medicaid & Dual conference, in Washington, DC, I’ve been able to hear from those who are involved in healthcare policy in the United States and what the future of it could look like.

The Medicare conference ended today with an address from Seema Verma, the administrator for CMS (Centers for Medicare/Medicare Services). Her message focused on some recent changes – such as:
  • The ability for Medicare Plans to negotiate on Part B medications (those administered by healthcare providers-  usually in office)
  • Loosening up of the ability for plans and agents to do more in sales and marketing meetings and events
  • Request for legislation for Pharmaceutical companies to list drug prices in advertisement
  • And now Medicare Advantage plans to offer telehealth services (the ability to speak to a provider either on a computer or phone for routine issues) to all members.
Ms. Verma said it took a while for this law to pass through Congress. The commercial markets have had telehealth services for about five or six years now. Medicare plans will roll this out in 2020.


Innovation isn’t the government’s strong point– what happens to this innovation if the government does take over healthcare for everyone?



How do we continue to find solutions for access to healthcare in rural areas? Access to a sick visit in urban areas can take a day or two to get an appointment, will government innovation solve this issue?  Access to social workers and other mental health providers is even more incredibly difficult - ask anyone in Columbia County, NY, for example.  

Telehealth has also taken off in mental health counseling – more people feel comfortable using this type of practitioner interaction. And, did you know – loneliness is a leading complaint from people now? It is becoming, yet, another epidemic. Having access to a mental health provider with just a call would be very helpful.

Yes, our system is broken. But does that mean we throw away the innovative solutions that are working? Or do we move forward and use best practices from the entire healthcare industry to pick up the pieces of our failing Medicare system?


Another session that got me thinking was a moderated tableside chat – between Lanhee Chen, Ph.D. from the Hoover Institute and Topher Spiro from American Progress. Topher was actually involved in the crafting of the Affordable Care Act under the Obama administration – the session was called, “Implications of the Midterm elections Including Medicare for All”. Pretty much out of the gate you could tell Dr. Chen was not a supporter of the ACA and Topher was. That said, they both had some really good points and both agreed (yes, if you can believe that folks agree in D.C.) that something has to be done. Perhaps a hybrid of employer, government and other solutions could end up being the solution to get more people covered in an affordable way.

What struck me most was a comment that Topher made. As he was working in the most recent defense of the ACA, a lightbulb went off, even though a majority of Americans, regardless of party – want access to healthcare, Republicans won’t sign on to fix the ACA aka Obamacare (aka Romney Care). A new bipartisan solution will have to come about to get buy-in. The ACA has too much history and negativity to be fixed. The phrase that comes to mind for me, “if you like your doctor you can keep them.” Can we, as a country, sit down and find a bi-partisan solution that can check off all these boxes?


The status quo is not working. 



The ACA has been picked apart so many times, it would sink faster than the Titanic at sea. Medicare doesn’t have enough money to sustain the current (and ever-growing) 130M beneficiaries. We need to stop yelling at each other, start talking and find a solution before it is too late. We have data, innovation, and experienced and intelligent industry professionals to make this happen.

Oh – and, go out and say hi to your neighbor, find a friend and fight off that loneliness. We need to come back together – not continue to push each other way. Everyone can use a shoulder to cry on at some time or just vent to – in this current world – it is even more important than ever.

Friday, March 9, 2018

The Tax Cut & Jobs Act did what to my HSA & adoption?



Normally, when you head into a new calendar year, you are informed in the prior year of increases in limits to benefits, such as Flexible Spending Accounts, Health Saving Accounts, deductible maximums.  

But, 2018 (and 2017 for that matter) - are not normal years.  Just last week, it was announced that due to the "Tax Cuts & Jobs Act" enacted at the end of 2017, not only overhauled our tax code, but it also affected some of our 2018 benefit limits because it changed the consumer price index (CPI) the following increases have been modified back to January 1, 2018:

1. Health Savings Accounts: 2018 maximum deposits for family plans were raised to $6,900.00  The revised maximum for 2018 is now $6,850.  You can read more about this below.




2. Adoption Assistance: 2018 original maximum was $13,840 and it was adjusted down to $13,810.

3. Archer Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs): 2018 original maximum was $4,600 and it was adjusted to $4,550.  


While the amounts may be de minimus to some, the administration and soft dollar costs of payroll adjustments, money being re-allocated will cost small & large businesses a like, more time & money to correct.  Employees who do not adjust their accounts face potential negative salary and or/tax implications at the end of the year.  

I never liked it when someone changed a rule after I started to play a game and I definitely don't like it when it left to the employee or business to fix or be penalized for it.  

Wednesday, January 31, 2018

Transparency & being a good business partner - my interview with PrimePay

I focus this blog a lot on what needs to be fixed in the healthcare and group benefit delivery system.  Recently, I sat down with PrimePay and discussed how as consultants, we CAN change the industry, and be a good partner while doing it.  Read the interview here.  

Tuesday, January 30, 2018

CHIP has a 6 year reprieve, but at what cost?

As I wrote last week, The Child Health Insurance Program (CHIP) has been renewed for 6 years.  The program expired on October 1, 2017, yet Congress delayed and could not come together to give the bipartisan program a revamp.  The delay was pointless, costly, a detrimental to necessary public health initiatives for our low-income citizens.  Everyone (me, you, and our elected Congress) knew the law would ultimately pass.  

Some members of Congress did take up the good fight.  Regretfully, this fight had to mix with Repeal and Replace (twice), then hold out for further clout, and only when the government shut down did our elected officials decide what they were willing to barter in order to renew and open up funding for state CHIP plans.

Four months - a third of a year-- we let a vulnerable population teeter on the edge of medical coverage uncertainty.  Parents of pediatric patients with life-threatening conditions waited with baited breath to see if they could afford treatment for their children. 

Why was affordable health care coverage for American children unnecessarily given the run-around for so long and at what price?  This political holdout had hard and soft dollar costs that we cannot recoup - money that could have been better spent on care for our children, but instead, it ended up in waste and allowed for interruptions in care.

Let's take a look:
  • The potential cost to shut down and freeze the Virginia CHIP Program in December: $300,000.  Understand that VA, AL, CO & UT were facing a 1/31/18 shut down and they needed a minimum of 6 weeks to get systems set for a shutdown.
  • Even with funding being secured, as late as December 27, Carolyn Engelhard, Associate Professor at the University of VA School of Medicine said it could cost Billions.  
  • VA, unsure of funding, paid $23,000 to send out letters notifying CHIP participants they may have to roll back coverage.  
    • Connecticut and Colorado sent out letters as well, assuming it cost them approximately the same as Virginia, that's another $46,000 wasted.
Virginia is quite transparent with their public health spending records. Looking at the cost of a well visit for a child based in 2015 ($117) and if we increased it by 20% since the data is 3 years old, - we'll assume that today the same well visit today would cost $141.  

Let's keep it simple - those warning letters and the potential system slow down cost $323,000 in Virginia. This same money could have been used to fund ~2,290 well-child visits. 

New communications will be sent to CHIP participants that were affected (another $23k). New procedures and policies will be drafted to prevent this from happening in the future. At the end of the day, we will hear that the children were taken care of, but undeniably this whole debacle was not fiscally responsible, nor pursued with any compassion toward American families that were affected. These families will remember the stress and uncertainty of this debacle for years to come. Once a strong, functioning, and reliable government program, CHIP is now perceived as vulnerable. 

From a bird's eye view, the CHIP funding delay should be remembered as a giant waste of our tax dollars and government spending.  Isn't the goal supposed to be curbing government waste and spending?  And shouldn't we want to ensure that those at risk are protected?  

In 2018, isn't THIS something we can all stand together on?

Monday, January 22, 2018

CHIP is renewed for 6 years aka "adults acting like children while children suffer"

The Child Health Insurance Plan (CHIP) has been renewed for 6 years.    Before you bring out the noisemakers and pop the champagne, let's look at what really has happened.  

CHIP expired on October 1st, 2017 and many States have been scrambling to figure out what they are going to do.  Yes, this is a win for our children but at what price?  What will our children think of us, using their healthcare as a political game?  What costs are associated with the states that have already started to shut down or slow down their coverage options?  The costs of sending out termination letters, adding levels of stress to families dealing with critical or chronic care for their children, while facing an uncertain future?

While the news and lawmakers may rally around and give themselves a pat on the back and serve this on a tray of victory, it's not.  Our representatives should be ashamed of not finding a consensus to renew this back in October.  

If we are not going to govern like adults when it comes to our children, then what, exactly, are we governing for?




Friday, December 8, 2017

Social Security, Medicare & Cheese


I remember visiting my grandmother in Texas as a child in the summer and she would have these frozen blocks of government "cheese" in her freezer.  Massive blocks - with important looking seals and eagles.  She got them to give to neighbors when they were in need.  

Apparently - this cheese was part of a larger program with the US Government when stockpiles got so large, they gave it away.  It was an entitlement, you didn't have to pay for the cheese, it was just given to you if you were entitled to it.  

This week, as I was listening to the never-ending pundits and politicians talk about the tax bill, one high ranking house leader mentioned that because of the bill, we are going to have to make cuts to entitlement programs, such as Medicare & Social Security.  $25B in Medicare cuts.  (AARP is not a fan, as you can imagine)

That gave me pause - so I googled entitlement and it brings up three definitions: 1. the fact of having a right to something, 2. the amount to which a person has a right, 3. the belief that tone is inherently deserving of privileges or special treatment.

Let's start with Social Security - signed into law by President Roosevelt on August 14, 1935, it created a social program to pay retired workers an income after retirement.  Taxes were collected starting in 1937 and regular benefits paid out starting in January 1940.  Who is eligible for this benefit - anyone who has worked for at least 10 years.

Now on to Medicare - The Medicare Act (Title XVII of the SS Act) was signed into law by President Johnson on July 30, 1965.  IT established Medicare, health coverage for the elderly and Medicaid a program for the poor.  Workers pay a tax for Medicare.  Who is eligible for this benefit - anyone who has worked for at least 10 years.  Then you are able to get Part A at no cost (hospital) and you pay a premium for Part B (outpatient or doctor services) - based on your income.

A couple who both make $44,000 in 2012 dollars who turned 65 in 2010 would have paid $722,000 into Social Security and Medicare.  

So if we apply the facts of these two programs to the definition of entitlement, I guess I can make a case that under definition 1 & 2 - someone would have the right to something - that they paid for their whole life - so if this was why it was an entitlement, I guess home ownership or automobiles are entitlements too.  

Now, let's look at 3 - the belief that you are deserving of special treatment - that doesn't hold water - one pays into this program and you have to meet certain criteria in order to be eligible for the benefits, i.e. working 10 years.  I don't think that I would define work as a special treatment.   

So - in a nutshell:
  • Cheese = OK, an entitlement
  • Healthcare for seniors or children and retirement benefits = money out of hard-working Americans' pockets, not an entitlement.
$25B in cuts is a lot of cheese, isn't it?

P.S. - And I use the term "cheese" loosely.



Friday, October 27, 2017

It's October 27, 2017, do you know if your children are covered?

Growing up, we would hear that PSA, "It is 10PM, do you know where your children are?"  I was always in front of the TV and wondered what children are out at 10PM????

Well - it is October 27th, 27 days past the expiration of the Child Health Insurance Program (CHIP) which funding should have been renewed by September 30.

Well, not only has Congress managed to instill a level of fear and panic in the actuarial world of insurance in 2017, they also let our children down.  What used to be an assumed renewal of funding has turned into finger pointing & partisan excuses on both sides of the aisle.  

And who loses, not Congress - they get their coverage through their state exchange.

Who loses? - 9 MILLION AMERICAN CHILDREN & EXPECTING MOTHERS.  


I don't need to have children to know that this is absolutely unacceptable to put any child in danger of losing access to their healthcare.  Not just the ability to see a doctor if they have a sore throat, but what about that 9-month-old in the Neo-Natal ICU?  What happens to her?  What about the newborn, born with a life-threatening illness?  

Is it worth the DC power trip to put any child at risk?  I don't think so.  This should be a guaranteed yes vote, with no string attached, no pork, no hesitation.

If they would take healthcare away from a child, what would they take away from an adult?